All guides · Guide · 3 min read
Bioethanol or electric fireplace: which should you choose?
For a real flame and some heat, choose bioethanol. For no combustion and no fuel to handle, electric. For a three-dimensional flame that is cool to the touch, water vapour.
In a flat or a rental, electric and water vapour are the simplest; bioethanol is still possible, subject to the building rules, the lease and your insurance.
Updated on · Lueur & Foyer
- 1Burnerper model
- 2Fuel tankcapacity on the sheet
- 3Safety clearanceper manual
Generic diagram: dimensions and safety clearances are those in each model’s manual.
01The three technologies side by side
| Criterion | Bioethanol | Electric | Water vapour |
|---|---|---|---|
| Flame | Real flame | Light effect, no combustion | Lit water mist, three-dimensional |
| Heat | 1.5 to 4.5 kW depending on burner | Depends on model: some include a heater | Depends on model: often no heating |
| Installation | No flue, no connection | A power socket | A socket and a water tank |
| Running cost | About €1.80 an hour (0.6 L/h, €3/L) | Electricity: output × price per kWh | Electricity and water |
| Handling | Refill cold, store the fuel | None | Fill the tank |
| Watch out for | Burns, ventilation, clearances | As for any electrical appliance | Tank care as per the manual |
| Standard | EN 16647-1 or -2 | Electrical appliance standards | Electrical appliance standards |
The bioethanol cost comes from Selectra (September 2026). For electric, multiply output by the price per kWh: for example, a 2 kW heater at the French regulated tariff of €0.2001 per kWh costs about €0.40 an hour; the flame effect alone uses far less.
02The flame: real or recreated
Bioethanol is the only one of the three that burns. Quelle Énergie speaks of flames that bring a touch of authenticity: that is the main reason to choose it.
Electric recreates a flame with light, without combustion. Water vapour sends up a fine mist lit by LEDs, which gives the effect depth. Realism varies a lot between models: judge it on video or, better, in front of the unit.
03In a flat
All three install without a flue. Electric and water vapour need a socket; bioethanol needs nothing, but it requires a ventilated room and storing a flammable liquid.
Generali says a bioethanol fireplace needs no building work and no prior permission in France, since it is not connected to anything. In a co-owned building, check your building rules: some restrict storing flammable materials in private units. If in doubt, ask your managing agent before buying.
For a unit built into a wall, Generali recommends a professional, whatever the technology.
04If you rent
Under French law a tenant must use the home “reasonably” (article 1728 of the Civil Code). A lease clause banning open flames or fuel storage applies: read your lease, and ask the landlord for written consent if in doubt.
Electric and water vapour avoid the question: they burn nothing and unplug the day you move out.
Either way, tell your home insurer: Generali advises declaring a bioethanol fireplace, and the French Insurance Code gives fifteen days to declare anything that increases the risk (article L. 113-2).
05Running budget
In use, bioethanol is the most expensive: about €0.48 per kWh of heat against €0.2001 for electricity on the French regulated tariff (Selectra, September 2026).
Electric and water vapour cost mostly at purchase; their flame effect uses little power. If you plan to light it every evening, work it out over a season: hours × hourly cost.
06The mood
Bioethanol gives what the other two cannot: a flame that really moves, heat you feel on your hands, the faint sound of burning.
Electric can be switched on for the look alone, even in summer. Water vapour is cool to the touch, which makes it worth considering near a walkway, in a bedroom or around children.
07Water vapour in brief
A water vapour fireplace sends up a very fine mist and lights it from below with LEDs: the flame has depth, but nothing burns.
It needs a water tank to be filled. How often, and which type of water, are given in the model’s manual. Our sources do not measure its effect on room humidity, so we do not claim one.
It is the least documented of the three: we found no independent test. See it running before you choose.
08Public venues
The conditions of article AM 20 of the French safety rules (an appliance complying with NF D 35-386, no combustible material within 2 metres, refilling with no public present, a ban in hotel rooms) apply to ethanol appliances (FFB, 2020).
That is why electric and water vapour are often studied first for a hotel or a restaurant. Approval always rests with your fire safety officer. See Professionals.
Frequently asked questions (4)
Which fireplace suits a flat with no chimney?
All three. Electric and water vapour are the simplest (a socket, no fuel). Bioethanol needs a ventilated room and building rules that do not ban storing flammable liquids.
Which is cheapest to run?
Electric. A kWh of heat from bioethanol costs about €0.48, against €0.2001 for electricity on the French regulated tariff (Selectra, September 2026), and an electric unit’s flame effect alone uses little power.
Does a water vapour fireplace give off heat?
Often not: the mist is cool. Some models include a supplementary heater. Check the model’s sheet.
Can a tenant install a bioethanol fireplace?
Yes, if the lease does not forbid it: read it and ask the landlord’s consent if in doubt, then declare the unit to your insurer. An electric or water vapour fireplace avoids the question.
Sources (6)
Pages read on 21/11/2026. Every figure in this guide points to one of them; anything we could not confirm has been removed.
- Quelle ÉnergieEthanol fireplaces: pros and cons (in French)undated page, read on 21/11/2026
- GeneraliBioethanol fireplaces: what are the benefits? (in French)20/01/2023
- LégifranceFrench Civil Code, art. 1728 (tenant obligations) and Insurance Code, art. L113-2 (declaring new circumstances), in French21/11/2026
- SelectraBioethanol fireplaces: cost per litre and safety (in French)04/09/2026
- FFB (French Building Federation)Ethanol fireplaces in public venues: what the rules say (in French)19/03/2020
- BSIBS EN 16647-1:2025, manually operated decorative fireplaces for domestic use (scope)published 30/09/2026